Inspector Vance and the Noir Magazines of the 1930s and ’40s

Share Button

One of the many fascinating things that Inspector John Vance packed away when he retired from the Vancouver Police Department in 1949 were several true crime magazines. He appeared in all of them. Reporters were intrigued by this scientist who was able to convict criminals through the tiniest piece of trace evidence, or determine death by poison, or through his forensic skills in serology and firearms examination.

Reporters moonlighted for these magazines and had cozy relationships with police and sources that gave them access to information and photos unheard of on any crime beat today.

The early magazines ran fictionalized versions of sensational crimes. In one ironically called Real Crime Cases, Vance takes a starring role in a story called the “Mystery of the Missing Mrs. Millard” based on a 1914 murder investigation. The case is the first chapter in Blood, Sweat, and Fear, and it’s fascinating to read the “real” version in the magazine. In the magazine, Vance becomes a detective and is even given lines and solves the case. In reality, it was the first police case he worked on, and his job was to test a stain found on the carpet to see if it was blood.

True crime magazines
A typical drugstore display of magazines in the early 1940s. Courtesy CVA 1184-3279

In another case that I wrote about in Blood, Sweat, and Fear, the story of two murdered police officers in Merritt written up in Master Detective was so detailed and accurate with accompanying crime scene photos that it resulted in a sharp warning from the trial judge.

Later Vance appears in Inside Detective with the headline “They couldn’t kill the crime doctor.” He appears again in Special Detective Cases in a feature called “He makes his own miracles,” and in May 1942, Vance is the subject of a three-page feature in Greatest Detective Cases “Vancouver’s Police Wizard: Inspector Vance.”

According to a recent Vancouver Sun story the Canadian market for detective magazines came to an end when “moral outrage led to a 1949 Canadian law banning pictorial depictions of the commission of crimes real or fictitious,” sucking all the fun from the articles.

Predictably, Canadian true crime was a lot milder than its US counterparts. These were more like soft porn that featured cartoon-like pictures of women bound and gagged.

Detective magazines had a longer run in the U.S., they lasted into the 1970s, True Detective, which launched in 1924, managed to hang on until 1996. While interest in true crime never waned, tabloid television replaced the magazine.

© All rights reserved. Unless otherwise indicated, all blog content copyright Eve Lazarus.

Share Button


  1. Melodramatic and salacious. My brother and I used to pool our dimes to buy the occasional copy, but had to hide them from our mother. Pulp fiction had the same sleazy sizzle to it.

  2. I remember seeing many of those magazines when I was a kid, and sometimes skimmed thru’ a few on visits to the local drugstore. I then became a big fan of many of the crime/murder-mystery/detective tv shows,
    I understand it’s a genre that’s not for everyone.
    And I also understand that too much detail could have serious negative consequences for many judicial cases.
    But a total ban?! I love how you say the ban ended up “sucking all the fun from the articles” …..maybe this was the true birth of ‘No Fun City’?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge