From Vancouver Exposed: Searching for the City’s Hidden History
Before Vancouver settled on its current City Hall on West 12th, it had been housed in a number of really interesting buildings.
The first council started out in a tent shortly after the Great Fire wiped out most of the city in 1886. The tent was on the CPR pier at the foot of Main Street. Chief Constable John Stewart is pictured second from left.
Three months later, the Sentell Brothers were contracted to build the first city hall at 149-151 Powell Street–a two-storey wooden structure. It took just a month to build and came in at under $1,300. But the city couldn’t afford the tab, and the Sentell Brothers took the unusual step of shutting them out until they came up with the cash.
Oppenheimer Bros Wholesale Grocers building 1898
The building quickly became too small for the growing city, and when David Oppenheimer was elected mayor in 1888, City Hall into his warehouse on Powell and Columbia. The building is remarkably still there, in a sketchy part of Gastown, rehabilitated and now owned by rock star Bryan Adams.
Oppenheimer was replaced by Frederick Cope as Mayor in 1892 and City Hall moved to the old Market Hall on Main Street (Westminster Avenue until 1910) in 1898 just south of the Carnegie Library at East Hastings and remained there for the next three decades. The building with its wonderful turrets was demolished in 1958.
In 1929 City Hall moved to the Holden Block at 16 East Hastings designed in 1911 by William T. Whiteway—the same architect who designed the Sun Tower and Kathryn Maynard’s Alexander Street brothel.
Since 1937 our art deco City Hall designed by Fred Townley has stayed at its current location on West 12th. You can thank (or blame) Mayor Gerry McGeer for the look and the location, the first time a major Canadian city had built its city hall outside of the city.
© All rights reserved. Unless otherwise indicated, all blog content copyright Eve Lazarus
16 comments on “A brief history of Vancouver’s City Halls”
I love the look of it. Wonderful, distinctive building, evocative of its period, as it should be. In September I’ll be once again staying in the street behind it. Impatient to be there.
I love all the pictures and the stories behind them. You make it all so interesting. thanks
Thank you for taking the time to comment, it’s very much appreciated.
Hi there. Love your site and all the interesting historical details. Love it! Came across this image today in the City of Vancouver Archives that shows City Hall in this building: http://searcharchives.vancouver.ca/index.php/city-hall-on-powell-street
It is also listed on the 1912 Goad’s Insurance Map as “Old City Hall” with an address of 149-151 Powell, just west of Main. I’m thinking maybe the Warehouse story might either be incorrect OR there is another chapter in the movements of the City Hall around our fair city. What do you think?
You may be right
https://vancouversun.com/news/local-news/this-week-in-history-1886-1948-vancouvers-first-council-is-locked-out-of-its-new-city-hall
[…] Hall, at that time, was in the Old Market Hall. Schooley and Armstrong were returning to City Hall from the bank, where they had picked up the […]
I am wondering why the story of the first city hall built following the fire is not mentioned here? It was built in a short time and while the Sentell Brothers were able to build it quickly, the city of Vancouver did not have the balance of $1250 to pay for their new building. So, the brothers kept the keys, locking the city of Vancouver out of their new City Hall until the balance was paid. It was finally paid and the brothers gladly handed over the keys. This city hall served until the Main Street location was opened. These brothers were responsible for building several homes in the Vancouver area, some of which are still standing today.
By the way, I have a sketch of that Powell Street building if you would like to see it.
Thank you for this spot to send messages.
Sincerely,
Georgie Brown, Kelowna BC – formerly of Vancouver
Thanks for writing. and yes, please send the sketch to info@evelazarus.com I’ll check into it next update.
A relevant article from today’s Sun
https://vancouversun.com/news/local-news/this-week-in-history-1886-1948-vancouvers-first-council-is-locked-out-of-its-new-city-hall?
[…] Schooley nor Armstrong seem to have suffered serious injury. City Hall, at that time, was in the Old Market Hall. The two City employees were returning to City Hall from the bank, where they had picked up the […]
[…] pushed for the new site of City Hall at its current Mount Pleasant location and raised much of the $1.5 million through Baby Bonds. In a […]
[…] pushed for the new site of City Hall at its current Mount Pleasant location and raised much of the $1.5 million through Baby Bonds. In a […]
[…] Market Hall […]
[…] I’m writing a book about John F.C.B. Vance, the first forensic scientist in Vancouver, and this week I wrote about his first day of work as the new City Analyst. My book is non-fiction, but sometimes you need some creative license. My challenge was to get to get Vance from his house in Yaletown to Market Hall, a lovely long-gone gothic building on Westminster (Main Street) which doubled as City Hall. […]
[…] building that should never have been torn down: The City Hall on Westminster (now Main) street was a robust turreted building that acted as Vancouver’s […]
[…] in 1890 and sat on Westminster Avenue (Main Street) near the Carnegie Centre on East Hastings. City Hall moved down the street into the Holden Block in 1929. Market Hall came down in […]