Cold Case Canada

CCC Podcast Header Image
A true crime podcast with Eve Lazarus
2024 Webby Nominee

Murder by Milkshake Part 2

FacebookTwitterShare

In 1965, Rene Castellani, a 40-year-old radio personality decided to murder his wife Esther with arsenic-laced milkshakes so could marry Lolly, CKNW’s 25-year-old receptionist. The couple had an 11-year-old daughter called Jeannine, who became the collateral damage in one of the most sensational murder cases of the 20th century.

This podcast episode is based on my book Murder by Milkshake: an astonishing true story of adultery, arsenic and a charismatic killer

Rene Castellani:

Rene Castellani was known for his outrageous stunts. Shortly before his wife’s death, he had climbed to the top of the BowMac sign on West Broadway and vowed to stay there until every last car on the lot sold. It took nine days.

Clowning around at Joyce Dayton’s children boutique with Esther and Jeannine, ca.1963. Courtesy Jeannine Castellani

While Rene was selling cars for a CKNW promotion, his wife Esther was in hospital. She had been ill for several months. At first she had stomach and lower back pain severe enough to keep her off work at the Kerrisdale children’s boutique, and then she had bouts of nausea and diarrhea which quickly turned into intense pain and vomiting. Her fingers and toes went numb. Esther saw several specialists, spent seven weeks in hospital, and went through more than 120 different tests before she died.

Mabel Luond (Esther’s mother), Esther and Jeannine on Granville Street, ca.1960
Disneyland:

The day after Esther’s funeral, Rene took Jeannine, Lolly and Don to Disneyland and soon the couple moved in together. In Vancouver, Esther’s doctor was still looking into the cause of her death. He went back over everything and realized that arsenic could have caused the symptoms. Dr. Moscovich had Esther’s body exhumed and the autopsy revealed that her arsenic levels were 1,500 times the normal arsenic content of the body.

Rene in handcuffs after his trial. Vancouver Sun, November 12, 1966
Arrested:

Rene was eventually arrested several months later when he and Lolly applied for a marriage license. While the case against Rene was all based on circumstantial evidence, there was a lot of it, including a box of arsenic-laden ortho triox weed killer found under his kitchen sink.

The Vancouver Police Department Homicide Squad in 1967. Bill Porteous second from right first row; Alex Reid top row left; Archie McKay top row, second from left. Courtesy Mike Porteous

New forensic technology was able to chart the amount of arsenic Esther had received through her nails and strands of her hair. What helped to convict Rene though, was that for the nine days he was sitting up on the BowMac sign there wasn’t any sign of poison and she became violently ill the evening Rene came down.

Roy Peterson’s depiction of Rene Castellani’s murder trial. Vancouver Sun, October 9, 1967

For many years Jeannine clung to her father’s innocence, even committing perjury during his trial. Rene was convicted of capital murder, but the death penalty was commuted to life in prison two weeks before he was scheduled to hang.

Within a few years, he was out on day parole, often visiting Jeannine with a different woman in tow. Within 12 years he had full parole,  remarried and became Rene the Roadrunner for an Abbotsford radio station.

Jeannine and Rene out on Parole, ca.1976. Courtesy Jeannine Castellani

© All rights reserved. Unless otherwise indicated, all blog content copyright Eve Lazarus.

My new book: Beneath Dark Waters: The Legacy of the Empress of Ireland Shipwreck is coming out in April 2025

Show Notes:

Music:   Andreas Schuld ‘Waiting for You’

Intro :   Mark Dunn

Interviews: Jeannine Castellani; Mike Porteous (retired) superintendent Major Crimes Vancouver Police Department; George Garrett (retired) CKNW investigative reporter

Buy me a coffee promo: McBride Communications and Media

Promo: Blood, Sweat and Fear: The Story of Inspector Vance

Sources:

Related:

Murder by Milkshake Part 1 https://evelazarus.com/s2-e22-murder-by-milkshake-part-1/

Guy in the Sky https://evelazarus.com/guy-in-the-sky-the-bowmac-sign/

The Maharaja https://evelazarus.com/the-maharajah-alleebaba/

Lolly, CFun and the brill bus https://evelazarus.com/lolly-cfun-and-the-brill-trolley-bus/

 

 

FacebookTwitterShare

11 comments on “Murder by Milkshake Part 2”

Eve, this is a remarkable condemnation of Canada’s justice system. Castellani should have been kept in a secure prison for life. And certainly not in the country club where he stayed for a short time. It’s the parole officers and the parole oard members who are not alligned with public sentiment. Too many social workers amongst them.

I did quite a bit of research on the prison system in the late 60s and early 70s for the book, and it was certainly an interesting time. Not sure things are much better now

Thanks for the updated Eve as I ordered your 4 signed books last year and read them all over the holidays. I rembemberd the story from the news. My three cousin’s also went to David Thompson at the same time, & in the 90’s I lived on 41st & Arglyle. I wonder if the McRoy was any relations to our family’s friend Doug? Jeannine was groomed so young she never stood a chance to against her Dad, and so happy that she came through all the devastation she endured. Good luck for your future as the truth will set you free and Happy New Year to all. 😊

Hi Eve, really love your podcasts and will check out your books too. Yes, he sounds like a textbook sociopath. The description Janine gave of his interactions is classic gaslighting: not just getting her to think he was innocent, but also convincing her that lies were reality. It’s hard to describe how convincing and persistent a sociopath can be once they have you in their web. I am glad she found the resilience and support to grow beyond her circumstances and become the person she is today.

Hi there Eve, enjoying all these podcasts.
My grand uncle was married to Detective Archie MacKay’s sister. His other sister Libby was Roddy Moore’s class teacher. I remember she told me that she took call from Roddy Moore’s mother, she also sat with children when they interviewed by police.
I’m in Scotland but spent quite a bit of time with Libby and Archie on visits to Vancouver when I was young.

I also am from same county as Robert McBeath came from and it’s where Archie and Libby’s parents grew up.
Kind regards

Alan

I

Happy New. Year Eve.

Yes lots, unfortunately Libby and Archie no longer with us and they certainly had a lot of stories.
Kind regards
Alan

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.