Every Place Has a Story

Vancouver Vanishes with Caroline Adderson

the_title()

Vancouver Vanishes

For a number of years Caroline Adderson wrote outraged letters to City Council about the large scale destruction of heritage houses in her Vancouver neighbourhood. When her letters went unanswered, Caroline sent pictures—she still didn’t get a response.

Vancouver Vanishes
Address: 3330 West King Edward Avenue
Built:1922
First Owner: Dr. Dallas G. Perry, Obstetrician
Status: DEMOLISHED

In January 2013, the award-winning author took her fight to social media and started posting pictures of beautiful character houses and short descriptions of their social history, including the address, when it was built, the first owner and occupation. Sometimes she’ll throw in photos of beautiful interiors and working appliances, just before they are crushed and sent to the landfill or off for recycling. The status is of course, always DEMOLISHED.

Vancouver Vanishes
Address: 3330 West King Edward Avenue
Built:1922
First Owner: Dr. Dallas G. Perry, Obstetrician
Status: DEMOLISHED

“For me, they are more than houses, they are cultural artifacts,” she says. “When you say John Smith, barber, and his wife Mary, suddenly you see this man doing something and a story is there and it makes it not only a horrible environmental waste, but also such a loss of narrative, story and history,” she says.

Vancouver Vanishes
Address: 3330 West King Edward Avenue
Built:1922
First Owner: Dr. Dallas G. Perry, Obstetrician
Status: DEMOLISHED

The FB page struck a chord with others who are passionate about the diminishing heritage stock in our city. Caroline has attracted a bunch of media attention and finally got the attention of City Hall. Now Caroline is the organizer and contributor to a fully illustrated book that was released this week called: Vancouver Vanishes: Narratives of Demolition and Revival.

Vancouver Vanishes
2947 West 31st

“This is a tiny tiny sample of what’s actually being demolished in Vancouver,” she says. “This year we will have the most demolitions in the last decade and this is happening right in the middle of the city’s Heritage Action Plan so it’s pretty disheartening. I think it’s something like 1,400 demolition permits that will be issued by the end of this year.”

Vancouver Vanishes
2947 West 31st

Caroline has contributed three pieces, one is about her own house, another about the Dorothies—a twin pair of houses that were saved from demolition and appear on the cover. My chapter covers the disappearing West End based on my blog, and other contributors include the Globe and Mail’s Kerry Gold, John Mackie from the Vancouver Sun, civic historian John Atkin, and poets Evelyn Lau and Bren Simmers. Michael Kluckner wrote the introduction.

Vancouver Vanishes
2947 West 31st

 

 

 

The Pantages Theatre

the_title()
The office-like exterior hid an eleaborate Interior
The Pantages Theatre

I took a drive past the Pantages Theatre at East Hastings and Main yesterday. It was pouring with rain and the Downtown Eastside looked even bleaker than normal, like something out of a Dostoevsky novel.

It’s hard to imagine that this skuzzy part of town was once the central business district, but go back a century and the Pantages was part of a thriving theatre district and downtown core.

The Pantages Theatre opened on Hastings Street in 1908 and was demolished in 2011.

Vaudeville

The Street Directories of 1908—the first time the Pantages Theatre appears by name—show the theatre surrounded by clothing companies, real estate offices and coffee houses.

Over the years, several groups have fought to save the former vaudeville theatre, one of a North American chain owned by Alexander Pantages. Our Pantages Theatre was the second that he built–his first opened in Seattle and no longer exists.

According to John Mackie the theatre was converted into a movie house in the late 1920s, and has gone by several names including the Royal, State, Queen, Avon, City Nights and the Sung Sing.

Demolition Order

This poor old pile of bricks has sat vacant since 1994—left to rot from the inside out. Attempts to hash out a deal with the city to restore the theatre failed, and to no one’s surprised, the city issued a demolition order last Thursday.

Pantages Theatre
Behind the Pantages Theatre, 2011

Heritage Vancouver calls it “demolition by neglect.”

You can’t see it from the street, but when I wandered down the back alley you can see the bulldozers have already pulled down everything behind the neighbouring buildings. What’s tragic is that there’s no development plan in place, we’ll be left with another gaping hole. Now it’s only a matter of days until it all comes down, and it will be just like it never was.

Related:

© All rights reserved. Unless otherwise indicated, all blog content copyright Eve Lazarus.

Chuck Davis (1935-2010)

the_title()
No one knew more about Vancouver than Chuck Davis
Chuck Davis

It’s too bad Chuck couldn’t be at his memorial service this afternoon. He would have loved it. For starters there were a couple of hundred people there—a totally eclectic crowd, pretty much like the guy himself. The only thing we had in common was that Chuck had touched us all in some way.

Local legends Dal Richards and Red Robinson were there. So was former mayor Sam Sullivan and Tourism Vancouver head Rick Antonson. I sat next to a guy who looked a bit familiar. Turned out to be George Bowering. There were people like John Mackie, John Atkin and Andrew Martin who shared Chuck’s love of history. There was at least one Vancouver tour guide and another acquaintance who worked with Chuck in Germany during World War 11. Mark Dwor, chair of the Canadian Academy of Independent Scholars was there with Yosef Wosk. Norm Grohman was a perfect choice for MC. He was in tears at the end.

Michael Conway Baker composed the music for the film and dedicated “Vancouver Variations” to Chuck’s memory. According to Baker, Chuck loved the oboe.

“He was Major Matthews times one hundred,” said Alan Twigg. “The city should have given him a job.” Hopefully, along with naming a day in his honour, the city will kick in some funds to help finish his book. Local journo Allen Garr told us he’s working with Harbour Publishing and other writers who are donating their time to finish Chuck’s legacy. The massive History of Metropolitan Vancouver is scheduled to hit bookstores in the fall—in time for Vancouver’s 125th birthday. Maybe then Chuck will really rest in peace.

See Daniel Wood’s excellent article on Chuck in the Tyee as well as  Mr. Vancouver: A blog about Chuck Davis for updates on his book.

© All rights reserved. Unless otherwise indicated, all blog content copyright Eve Lazarus.