Every Place Has a Story

West Coast Modern: Selling Architecture as Art

the_title()

For the last year or so I’ve been receiving emails from a realtor named Trent Rodney at West Coast Modern. They come with an invitation to drop by one of the dwindling stock of West Coast Modern houses on the North Shore, sip a cocktail, eat catered food and listen to jazz. The houses are all designed by well-known mid-century architects such as Fred Hollingsworth, Arthur Erickson, Ned Pratt, Peter Kafka, Barry Griblin, and Henry Yorke Mann.

One of around 15 invite-only preview events. This one for a West Coast Modern house designed by Bob Lewis on Greenbriar way in 1954

When he first started as a realtor, Trent says he’d see a post-modern house come on the market and wish that he was the agent. “I would drive by two months later and it would be torn down. It was a slap in the face.”

Trent says he sees himself as an art dealer, representing the work of architects.

Last Thursday, more than 300 people turned up to an Arthur Erickson-designed house in West Vancouver. Built in 1981, it’s now listed at almost $3.3 million. There’s a public open house this Sunday.

5323 Montiverdi Place, West Vancouver. Courtesy West Coast Modern

“I’m a big believer in emotion. When people come to one of our events, they are excited about the house,” he says.

Trent sends out around 15,000 invitations to a carefully curated database of people in the creative community who already live in, or are most likely to love these West Coast Modern houses. They include designers, artists, architects, musicians, and for the higher end stuff, people working in the tech industry.

Realtors are not welcome.

Ned Pratt House, West Van. Eve Lazarus photo 2013 from Sensational Vancouver

It’s a unique and costly marketing strategy, but seems to be working. “I’m able to command a 10 to 15 percent design premium for a West Coast Modern house,” he says. “A renovated house in Edgemont Village, for instance will sell for around $2.2 million. I’m able to achieve close to $2.5 million for the same size house because I’m able to attract the design community and get multiple offers.”

Trent says his goal is to keep these houses out of the hands of the developers. He spends a chunk of his day pouring through the more than 500 listings on the North Shore and highlighting the houses that he believes should be saved and making sure buyers are aware of them.

Peter Kafka Forest House, built 1961 West Vancouver, Courtesy West Coast Modern

The problem is, these houses are often on big lots zoned for much larger houses, and realtors pitch them as lot value where you can “build your dream home” ignoring for most of us, that like this long-gone Fred Hollingsworth house on Newmarket Drive, these are our dream homes.

When I asked Trent, which house he thought was the greatest loss, I was expecting him to say the Graham house or one of the expensive cliff hugging West Vancouver homes. Instead, he told me it was the Watts Residence, a fairly modest house designed by Fred Hollingsworth.

Watts Residence 3635 Sunnycrest, North Van (1951-2019)

The Watts Residence was recently replaced with the kind of cookie cutter house that is homogenizing our neighbourhoods. Hollingsworth’s own North Van house which he designed and lived in for more than six decades, came up for sale in October 2018. His son, starchitect Russell Hollingsworth hired Trent’s firm to sell the house to someone who would save it.

The Graham House, designed by Arthur Erickson in 1962, demolished 2007

“People say the city should do more, but if you keep it in the hands of the people who live in the houses, they are the custodians. They like the architecture, they pay more, and they are not going to tear it down,” he says.

Former owner Kerry McPhedran at Boyd House in 2012. Eve Lazarus photo

Some good news. It looks like Ron Thom’s Boyd House will live to see another day, after West Van voted to allow subdivision of the lot and short term rentals of the house.

Forrest-Baker house built in 1962 and currently under a temporary protection order by the District of West Van. Selwyn Pullan photo

Unfortunately, the fabulous Ron Thom-designed Forrest-Baker house may not be so lucky. There is currently a temporary protection order in place to try and stop its demolition.

© All rights reserved. Unless otherwise indicated, all blog content copyright Eve Lazarus.

Fred Thornton Hollingsworth

the_title()

Fred Thornton Hollingsworth was born in England in 1917. He pioneered West Coast Architecture on the North Shore and died in 2015 at the age of 98.

While Arthur Erickson, Ned Pratt and Ron Thom have imprinted their West Coast style of architecture all over Vancouver, Fred Thornton Hollingsworth is the architect most responsible for the look of post war North Vancouver. Inspired by Frank Lloyd Wright, Hollingsworth met the legend in 1951 and turned down a job offer to work with him, opting instead to develop his own style.

Fred Hollingsworth’s own North Vancouver house is featured in Sensational Vancouver

Fred Hollingsworth in the Trethewey Residence he designed in 1961. Photo courtesy of Selwyn Pullan.
Fred Hollingsworth in the Trethewey Residence he designed in 1961. Photo courtesy of Selwyn Pullan.
West Coast Architecture:

Lee Atwell grew up in a Hollingsworth house.

Her parents bought the “Watt’s Residence” from the original owners in 1965. It was built for $15,000 in 1951.

Designed by Fred Thornton Hollingsworth
3635 Sunnycrest Drive, North Vancouver

Lee’s dad died this year, and she and her sister Bev, who both live out of province, put the house on the market – only the third time in the sixty years since it was built.

“It was my Dad’s wish to live in the house until the time he passed at the age of 87—he loved the house so much,” Lee said. “I feel not only was it my parents who influenced our aesthetic tastes and deep connection to the natural world, but also the house itself. The house helped to define who we are today.”

Lee and Bev’s fear was that new owners would want to raze the place and put up something new. So they were immensely relieved when they found buyers who also love the house. Instead of tearing it down, they’ve hired Fred’s son Russell Hollingsworth, to design an addition in keeping with his father’s philosophy.

The Neoteric House:

I’ve written about Hollingsworth before, but Lee’s comments made me want to revisit some of his architecture, because when it comes to post-war architecture, Fred Hollingsworth is a rock star. He invented the Neoteric style where Lee, Bev and their older brother grew up—affordable family housing with a small footprint, open plan and simple post and beam construction. As early as 1946, Hollingsworth was including radiant floor heating, clerestory windows and skylights to let in lots of light and old growth wood paneling.

As Lee will tell you, a Hollingsworth house is part design, part art and part architecture.

Designed by Fred Hollingsworth for Jack and Marion Moon
2576 Edgemont Boulevard, North Vancouver
Reconnecting with Nature:

The Moon Residence was built for $11,000 in 1950. It came onto the market for $1.38 million this summer. Like Lee’s house, it is set in a private park-like setting and looks like part of nature rather than something imposed upon it. It’s the type of house that the environmentally friendly should aspire to, and fortunately there are still many Hollingsworth houses in existence–I counted 22 in the District of North Vancouver’s inventory of modern architecture.

“I’ve always said a home is an escape from the world; a place to which you escape to reconnect with nature,” Hollingsworth told writer and urban designer Bob Ransford.

“My clients were all individuals. Many people had different interests. I tried to get into their lives. I tried to find out how they used their space.”

In fact, Hollingsworth, who will turn 95 in January, still lives in the house he designed for his family in 1946 at 1205 Ridgewood Drive in Edgemont Village.

While his name stands for West Coast Modernism and small residential homes, Hollingsworth’s architectural range is astounding. He designed the building that houses UBC’s Faculty of Law in 1971, and in 1993, he designed Nat Bosa’s West Vancouver waterfront mansion at 130 South Oxley Street. In 2005, Vancouver Magazine ranked it as the second most expensive property in BC; assessed at $24 million, with a market value of more than $30 million.

Related:

© All rights reserved. Unless otherwise indicated, all blog content copyright Eve Lazarus.