Every Place Has a Story

Vancouver’s Missing Buildings

the_title()

Janet Stewart was going through her mother Edna’s things after she passed away recently and came across four sketches by Frits Jacobsen. They showed various Vancouver buildings in the late 1960s. Janet googled his name, came across a story by Jason Vanderhill on my blog, and kindly sent me photos.

Hornby and Nelson Street. Frits Jacobsen, 1969
Hornby and Nelson:

I posted Jacobsen’s drawing of the corner of Hornby and Nelson Streets from 1969 on my Facebook page Every Place has a Story. Barry Leinbach commented that in 1968 he was working at a part time job in the parking lot across the street (now part of the law courts). He saw smoke coming out of the house on the corner. “I phoned the fire department and fortunately they saved most of the house, but they never repaired it.” At the time, Barry studied at King Edward campus, which burned down in 1973.

It was the first time that Heather Lapierre had seen the sketch. She said that the house was once 918 Hornby Street and that her great grandparents lived there when they came to Vancouver in 1893. I jokingly asked if she had a photo with the family standing on the front porch. Turns out that she did.

From L-R Walter Thicke, Harold Thicke, Clara Thicke, Marjorie Thicke, Claude Thicke, Violet Thicke and Walter Thicke Junior (Heather’s grandfather). 918 Hornby Street, 1893, courtesy Heather Lapierre

“I had no idea that the house was still there in the 70’s. I wish I had known and could have seen it,” she says. “It was only when my mother passed in 2000 that I inherited all these photos that nobody had ever talked about or showed me, many of which are unlabeled and remain a mystery.”

False Creek:

Heather also sent a photo of her paternal great grandparents first home. “It was just listed in the directory as False Creek, but on the reverse, written by my grandmother, it says, ‘first home of James and Ellen Findlay. Bruce Findlay with the barrow. False Creek 1889’.” James beat out LD Taylor in 1912 to become mayor of Vancouver. “When he was mayor, James Findlay lived at 1428 Robson and my father was born in that house. I have never been able to find a photo of the Robson Street house. It would have been torn down to make way for the Landmark Hotel – now also demolished,” she says.

The back of the photo says: “First home of James & Ellen Findlay. Bruce Findlay with the barrow. False Creek 1889.” Courtesy Heather Lapierre
Buntzen:

Heather’s grandfather Matt Virtue was one of the first powerhouse operators at Buntzen on Indian Arm and she was born there. Her story is in Vancouver Exposed.

Buntzen |Power Station
Heather Lapierre beside Power House #1 in 1953.

It makes me wonder how many family albums are holding photos like these. If you have one of an early Vancouver building or event and know where it was, please send a copy to eve@evelazarus.com and we’ll add it to Vancouver’s history.

1431 Robson Street (between Broughton and Nicola) is now the 12-storey Riviera Hotel recently assessed at $26.7 million. Frits Jacobsen, 1968 courtesy Janet Stewart

© Eve Lazarus, 2022

Related:

 

 

 

 

 

 

Aborted Plans: Deadman’s Island

the_title()

Members of the Town Planning Commission passed a resolution stating that they were not in favour of Deadman’s Island as a site for a proposed museum of Vancouver art, historical and scientific society. It was declared the Coal Harbour site was too inaccessible—Province: April  9, 1932

It continues to amaze me that Stanley Park has survived, despite all the attempts to develop it over the years.

In 1912, there was a push to “transform” Lost Lagoon into Grand Round Pond, with a surrounding museum, stadium and amusement park. There would be ornamental gardens, fountains a children’s playground, library and Georgia Street would be the “Champs-Elysees.”

Plans for Lost Lagoon in the Vancouver Sun, December 28, 2018

Fortunately, commonsense prevailed. Said Mayor James Findlay: “Thomas Mawson may be the finest architect in the world, but he cannot put Stanley Park back for us once it is destroyed.”

In the 1960s and ‘70s there were three attempts to turn Seasons Park—the 14 acres at the entrance—into a massive hotel and condo complex.

Sharp and Thompson Architects drawing of a proposed museum at Deadman’s Island in 1930. Courtesy VPL #7899

And in the early ‘30s there were plans to plop a castle-like museum building complete with citadel, on Deadman’s Island.

Sharp and Thompson Architects drawing of the Pacific Museum for Deadman’s Island. Courtesy VPL #7898

Measuring just 3.8 hectares, and attached to Stanley Park by a short causeway, Deadman’s Island, or Skwtsa7s (meaning island), has an amazing history. It was a battle site. It was an indigenous burial ground, where the dead were placed in wooden coffins and buried both in the ground and up in the trees. When small pox hit, it was used to quarantine the victims, and later bury those who didn’t make it. The land has also claimed British Merchant seaman, people from Moodyville, victims from the Great, and workers killed while extending the CPR line from Port Moody to Coal Harbour. One article says West Vancouver’s Navvy Jack is buried there.

Deadman’s Island seen just behind the second CPR station at the foot of Granville Street in the early 1900s. Courtesy VPL #9834

In 1930, the federal government leased the island to the city. Shortly after, the city commissioned Sharp and Thompson Architects to draw up designs for Pacific Museum. It didn’t get very far, and in 1944, became the site of HMCS Discovery Naval Reserve.

When the 99-year lease came up for renewal in 2007, Mayor Sam Sullivan tried to make it publicly accessible. He told the Globe and Mail he wanted a ferry service from downtown and a museum that could preserve and display the maritime heritage of native people.

Vancouver in 1933 with Deadman’s Island in the background. Courtesy VPL 4368

The Musqueam just wanted it back.

Except for an open house once or twice a year, which I always seem to miss it, the site remains off limits.

Sources:

© All rights reserved. Unless otherwise indicated, all blog content copyright Eve Lazarus.