Every Place Has a Story

St. Andrews-Wesley Church’s $30 Million Dollar Makeover

the_title()

I have just acquired a piece of St. Andrews-Wesley Church. A rug that’s worn in all the places that you’d expect of something that has graced the entranceway of this downtown heritage building for eight decades and hosted thousands of multi-denominational feet.

The renovations were made possible by the sale of church land and a 20-storey condo tower in 2002.St. Andrews-Wesley church at Burrard and Nelson is a special kind of place, and I was lucky to get a tour from Kathy Murphy last month before the church closes for a $30 million makeover.

It’s the first time I’ve been inside the church, and even in its less-than-perfect self, it’s breath-taking. From the stained-glassed windows to the gothic tower, it’s easy to see why people want to get married or buried there, play music, shoot movies, and yes, even worship.

St. Andrews Presbyterian Church at 686 Richards Street ca.1934 (now a 10-storey building designed by Zoltan Kiss in 1974 and the new home of Canada Post) Courtesy Vancouver Archives

While the Church has operated from the corner of Burrard and Nelson since 1933, it was the result of a merger between St. Andrews Presbyterian Church and Wesley Methodist, both designed by William Blackmore, and both demolished in the early ‘30s.

Wesley Methodist Church at the corner of Burrard and West Georgia in 1908. Built (1900-1904) courtesy BC Archives B-01433

It was the Great Depression when the current church opened, and there wasn’t a lot of cash. The pews were made from fir instead of oak. The bell tower didn’t have a bell, and the planned terrazzo floor became a cheap lino stop-gap. The temporary fix became permanent, and will now be updated along with a seismic upgrade, a new copper roof, and an electrical system that will also light up the incredible stained-glass windows.

January 2019. Eve Lazarus photo

The Mandela of Compassion will go back after the rehab, and its very presence is an indication that this is a different kind of church. Made of sand by three Buddhist monks over three days, the Mandela looks like an exquisite tapestry. Normally, the monks, who do not believe in having material things stick around, would blow the sand away when they’d finished, but church officials talked them into letting it stay.

The Mandela of compassion, made in three days in 2009

The pipe organ—the largest in Vancouver—is off to Montreal for a refit. While we were up there inside the guts of the organ, Darryl Nixon, Minister of Music, started playing the music he’d chosen for the following Sunday’s service.

Darryl Nixon, playing the pipe organ. January 2019. Eve Lazarus photo

The chapel is as an interesting room. Aside from hosting Tony and Tina’s wedding for 14 years, it has a 14-foot tracker organ (that’s for sale). The room has been used for small weddings and for yoga, the pews long ago repurposed into a cabinet, a table, and a casket for the carpenter.

Kathy Murphy with the church’s oldest artifact. Eve Lazarus photo

The Church is expected to be closed for up to two years. But it’s not too late to see it. Services run as normal tomorrow Sunday February 3.

© All rights reserved. Unless otherwise indicated, all blog content copyright Eve Lazarus.

Thurlow and Alberni Streets: then and now

the_title()
752 Thurlow Street
Garden family at 752 Thurlow Street, ca1890s. Photo courtesy Anders Falk

This story appears in Vancouver Exposed: Searching for the City’s Hidden History.

Anders Falk is a Vancouver realtor with deep roots in the city. His great, great grandparents William and Mary Henderson Garden arrived in Vancouver from Helensburgh, Scotland, via Liverpool and a cross Canada train trip in April 1889. William opened up Garden and Sons Wholesale Tea and Coffee on East Hastings. By 1894, Murchies has broken their monopoly on the tea business, and William and Mary and their two sons William and John have moved into a new house at the corner of Thurlow and Alberni Street.

222 East Hastings Street
Garden and Sons Wholesale Teas, 222 East Hastings Street, ca.1890s. Photo courtesy Anders Falk

William died in 1897, and the following year, the business has disappeared from the directory. John became a lumber broker and William Junior played in a band and worked at the Bay for his day job. The Gardens remain at 752 Thurlow until 1903. Fortunately one of the Garden family was an avid photographer and was able to capture the family’s various activities—at the house, a boat at the rowing club, and biking in Stanley Park.

William and Mary Garden
William and Mary Garden family in Stanley Park mid-1890s. Photo courtesy Anders Falk

Anders says Joe Fortes taught the Garden kids to swim at nearby English Bay.

William Lamont Tait, a wealthy retired lumber and real estate tycoon, is the next resident at 752 Thurlow. Tait must have spent much of the next few years planning and supervising the building of Glen Brae, his Shaughnessy mansion on Matthews. Completed in 1911, Glen Brae, named for Tait’s Scottish homeland, was dubbed “the Mae West” by locals because of its two outlandish turrets. Tait died in 1919, and in 1925, his former house became the headquarters of  the KKK. More recently it has found a nicer use as Canuck Place.

752 Thurlow Street
752 Thurlow Street with Wesley Methodist Church in the background ca1900 VPL 7153

The house on Thurlow Street and Alberni, like most large places in the West End, went through a number of uses—at one point it was a YWCA, a nursery, and during the First World War, it was occupied by the Canadian Medical Army Corps.

Rear of 754 Thurlow Street in 1956 CVA Bu P508-19
Rear of 754 Thurlow Street in 1956 CVA Bu P508-19

Between 1924 and 1940, 752 Thurlow showed up as the Vancouver Women’s Building in the directories, and in 1941 it was taken over by the Salvation Army.  Surprisingly, it looks like it survived until at least 1956, and at some point went through a street change to #754.

752 Thurlow Street, 1974. CVA 778-432
752 Thurlow Street, 1974. CVA 778-432

In 1966, 752 Thurlow was a three-storey building next to the Manhattan Apartments and occupied by Oil Can Harry’s. The club stayed there for the next 11 years.

752 Thurlow Street, 1974. CVA778-433
752 Thurlow Street, 1974. CVA778-433

The Carlyle, a 21-storey tower replaced the Thurlow Street building in 1989. Its address is now on Alberni.

The Carlisle, 1060 Alberni Street
The Carlyle, 1060 Alberni Street

© All rights reserved. Unless otherwise indicated, all blog content copyright Eve Lazarus.